Support and Resistance Lines

The concepts of resistance and support are part of the foundations of technical analysis. Like trend lines, resistance and support convey assumptions about price patterns that are ambiguous. Just when is resistance or support broken? When is resistance and support simply being probed? Current technical analysis of resistance and support treat those concepts as firm and quantifiable. They are not. We can see the inherent ambiguity in finding resistance and support

Price patterns such as triangles and channels are patterns that exhibit similar degrees of vagueness and are imprecise when the trader attributes
powers to the patterns that they do not have to predict future price direction Keep in mind that the patterns, which are perceived by traders, are
subjective and at best ex-post facto. They are easy to see after they have formed.

True patterns in nature are mathematical and can be tested by scientific methods. More importantly, they are intersubjective, which means that other people can confirm them.

Price patterns are flawed because they are bestcase interpretations. However, patterns do provide
evidence of the status of emotions in the market.
Fibonacci levels are among the most popular tools for trading and do give insight into the nature of price action. Although the field of technical analysis ascribes nearly magical powers to Fibonacci levels, they are still not reflective of any inherent direction.

When prices seem to move in Fibonacci retracement ratios it is because that is the way energy moves everywhere (the famous Nautilus shell is a classic illustration of Fibonacci
patterns, and the proportions of the human face follow Fibonacci ratios), but this does not mean that they predict where the price is going. Furthermore, markets recognize where the Fibonacci points are and use them to create trading triggers. This creates a self-fulfilling process. Fib lines need to be seen as providing zones of possible resistance and support.

The most important weakness in applying Fibonacci analysis relates to the confusion of where to locate a bounce or break off a fib line. This kind of thinking creates a lot of room for error. Just when can a break of a Fibonacci line be considered a break? A break is a very subjective concept. Do we consider a break when the price reaches above or below a Fib line? Or do we have to wait for a candle to close more than once above such a line? The answer may vary among different traders
Chart wave analysis (Elliott Wave) is another popular form of technical/teleological analysis that offers traders the promise of finding and riding a direction more accurately.

The problem with wave analysis is that it is not falsifiable. Prices are defined as being in waves that are part of an impulse or a corrective sequence. Within each sequence there are mini waves as well. Those who follow wave analysis find comfort in this detailed set-up, until prices do not follow the wave prediction. Rather than accepting the fact of being wrong, wave analysts will say that the price is correcting and then will resume back in the right direction. Many traders have heard the statement: the price will go down and then go up.

This is nonsense. It is subjective and vague. It is misleading to the trader who wants to use a method that is reliable. When is a wave based trade wrong? Wave trading is a form of forecasting that has huge degrees of ambiguity. Riding the wave is easy when one is looking in the rear-view mirror.

Read More

What is a Currency Pair Price?

A Fundamental View
An exclusive technical analysis view of markets, and in particular cur-
rency pairs, is highly flawed. The weaknesses and limits of technical anal-
ysis starts with a misunderstanding of what currency prices are all about.
The currency pair is, from a technical analysis view of market reality, a
point on the X–Y price axis. Charts visualize the price behavior. 

For example, if the EURUSD has moved 20 pips, from 1.1700 to 1.1720, a
line chart will show how this movement has occurred. Candlestick charts
show open, high, low, and close prices per unit of time (minute, hour, or
other time slices). The X axis represents time. Simple enough. But is that
what a price really is? The fact is that it is more than a measure on a X–Y
axis.

The fundamental viewpoint asserts that a currency price and its accompanying charts, are codes that are really enciphered signatures of expectations. A better understanding of how to unlock the codes within each currency pair will enable traders to profitably ride the expectation waves that move currency prices.

Flaws in Technical Analysis
The question arises: If technical analysis has these flaws, why is it so dominant? The answer is rather simple. The dominance of technical analysis as a tool for traders is not because technical analysis is totally effective, but because it is easy to sell systems and courses offering hyperbolic performance promises. It is natural that traders want to find the holy grail for predicting direction. As a result, responding to the desires and hopes of traders, there is extensive marketing of signals and systems, and courses that teach set-ups to respond to this demand.

Some systems and signals are profitable. None are profitable all of the time. The products of the trading industry are designed to be produced with minimal viability, because speed to the market is a more important priority than performance effectiveness. As a result, a total reliance on technical set-ups presents many flaws. Let us explore further some of the deep flaws in using technical analysis.The first deep flaw in exclusive reliance on technical analysis is psychological and philosophical. The very premise that one can predict that a price will reach a target is fraught with problems. The price target is in reality not technical in nature. It is a fabricated human construction. It is as subjective as searching for and finding a face in the clouds.

If you look for one you will find it, but it is delusional to believe that the face in the clouds really exists. Similarly, a profit target is a point of hope in the price arena. But in trading, “hopium” is not a useful drug.The very act of thinking that there is a target inherent in the currency pair price or pattern is also teleological (defined as inferring something has an intention).

Inferring intention is a common attribute of human behavior because it is more comforting to deal with an assumed intention then to deal with uncertainty. Consider the following statements: “The price wants to go to the next Fibonacci level”. “The price will bounce off resistance and then move to support”. “The price will break the outer trend line and then move to the inner trend line.” These types of comments are heard every day by traders and reflect the flaw that is inherent in teleological thinking in trading.

The fact is that a price does not know where it wants to go, because the price is really an instant in time of a balance between bullish and bearish expectations. A target also has the effect of suppressing profitability. Many traders who put on a trade that reaches a target price often take profit at that target, only to learn that the profits would have been higher.

Technical profit targets are best used as guides only.

A second powerful source of error and weakness in trading analysis is the use and analysis of trend lines. An uptrend is technically defined as when a price has a higher high and a higher low. A downtrend, conversely is defined as when a price has a lower high and a lower low. A popular saying is: “the trend is your friend.” Going with the trend seems like a good approach. But keep in mind that the trend is your friend until it is at an end. Trend analysis offers a great deal of ambiguity in detecting a shift in the trend.

When is it really over? Is it at a break of a line? How thick is the line? Is it 10 pips? This difficulty of defining a break in the trend applies to both intraday and longer durations.Central banks have a very hard time pinpointing just when a break in inflation trends is occurring. 

That is why they notoriously act too late and allow inflation to go too far, or too early, and put breaks on growth, stimulating a recession. Precision of projecting where prices are going is a common challenge to both traders and policy markets. Of course, lines do not exist and are just heuristic devices, which is a method to get a sense of the boundaries of price action. Lines are mathematical inventions to overlay on what we see. At best, a trend is a map of a path of prices. It leaves a great deal of room for error. It is a very low resolution map.

Read More

What is fundamental analysis??

Fundamental analysis, or a fundamental view of currency markets, is widely misunderstood. It is not simply about the economic conditionsfacing a country.

Fundamental analysis, when properly understood, contains sentiment analysis. Let us state this another way. Fundamental analysis deals with economic forecasts and expectations about economic metrics such as CPI (consumer price index), GDP (gross domestic product), employment, and so on. These fundamental expectations involve longer and medium-term durations.

The exact mix of expectation durations is, in fact, always changing.Sometimes expectations of economic outcomes a year ahead may impact current price action. At other times,the immediate geopolitical and global economic conditions have an immediate impact.

In a way, this view of a fundamental structure behind currency movements is similar to recent discoveries in physics of the Higgs boson field.In that major discovery, it has been proven that electrons get their mass as they go through the Higgs boson field. In currency trading we can say

that prices get their direction and strength of direction as they go through a field filled with fundamental expectation forces. Sentiment is the bridge and transmission channel, between long-term and short-term economic expectations that directly act upon the price.

Within the rubric of fundamental analysis, sentiment analysis focuses on current expectations about whether prior fundamental forecasts are correct. In other words, sentiment is the measure of the immediate change in expectations, caused by data releases, geopolitical crises, or any

other information shock that reaches the markets. Sentiment is about both long-term and short-term expectations.

Sentiment is how the market expresses emotions. Emotions are always about something and in currency markets emotions are generally about risk and uncertainty. Traders,therefore, need to diagnose what the market movements are about.This contrasts greatly with the current, dominant technical view of markets and currency .

Read More